But I couldn't give up on McSweeney's after only one rejection. In my heart I was sure that it was secretly a good online humor site, even though my friends kind of thought it was an asshole, and that, with my constant, slavish love and devotion, McSweeney's would eventually realize that it was ready for a more mature and serious list. So I sent this.
1. Man, those riders are young. 2. And you don’t see riding like that every day. 3. The Young Riders are just like the Young Guns,
but with more riding.
4. Shit, they’re riding again.
You will not be surprised to learn it was rejected.
*Not being a 12 year old girl, you are probably unfamiliar with the train wreck of a series that was The Young Riders. Let me just say this: it has a Baldwin in it who is not Alec. **I know, I know - it was a pathetic attempt. I am brought low by it. I deserve rejection. I am not worthy of McSweeney's affection. I am worthless.
I feel it's time to get real. I mean really real. For realzies.
Here goes: All I want in life is for some online entity that caters to sardonic, over educated, underemployed, check-out-my-obscure-t-shirt, of-course-I-love-Mars-Volta, too-cool-4-school urban hipsters to acknowledge me.
I'm here! I'm funny! Look at me, goddamnit! It's like high school all over again.*
But like an awkward, bookish, flat-chested, boyish-looking teen girl attempting to get the leader of the skateboarding stoners to invite her to eat her lunch outside while watching him ollie and smoke, I am rebuffed time and time again. Like a big loser.**
So, as a way of masochistically poking the point of rejection deep into the eye of failure, I am going to post the first of many rejected McSweeney's Lists submission.
FACIAL HAIR TRENDS
TO REPLACE THE IRONIC MUSTACHE***
1. Metonymic goatee
2. Anaphoric sideburns
3. Synechdochic eyebrows
Total content of rejection email: "Tempting, but still a pass."
*Without the hallucinogens and the cutting, natch. **This is an entirely fictional situation. I've always been stacked and super-popular. ***I mean, COME ON. This list is perfect. You need a Master's degree in Comparative Lit just to get the punchline, and it's about a phenomena familiar only to coastal urbanites. Could it get anymore obscure and elitist?!?! Fuck you, McSweeney's.